Do You Leave Your Butter on the Counter, or Keep it in the Fridge?

Do You Leave Your Butter on the Counter, or Keep it in the Fridge? Maverick bought new butter at Detwiler's called Better Butter. It says you can leave it on the counter for 6 weeks. Lulu says no way, she has to keep her butter cold. It seems people are split on where to keep the butter. LISTEN HERE